Green Book

Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!
(Previous editions of Reeling can be downloaded from Vimeo by clicking this link.)

  Green Book

Tony Vallelonga (Viggo Mortensen), known as Tony Lip to his pals, is a bouncer and small time hustler looking for work to support his wife and two kids in the Bronx when the Copacabana Club closes for renovations. He gets a lead on a driving job, but when he meets Dr. Shirley (Mahershala Ali), he was expecting a white doctor, not a renowned black pianist expecting valet services.  But Tony relents after Shirley calls and speaks to his wife Dolores (Linda Cardellini), asking her permission to take her husband away for two months and ceding to Tony's demands.  The bigoted Goomba is in for quite the education when he learns that driving through the Deep South with an African American in 1962 requires following advice in the "Green Book."

Cowriter (with Nick Vallelonga, Brian Hayes Currie)/director Peter Farrelly has come a long way from "Dumb and Dumber" with this heartfelt and crowd pleasing true story about a most unlikely friendship. Tony is unrefined, a talker with a New Yawk accent, a sloppy and voracious eater and chain smoker with little education but a lot of street smarts.  He's also an extreme bigot, appalling his wife when she finds two glasses in the trash, deposited there by her husband because they'd been used by two black repairmen. Dr. Shirley, on the other hand, is worldly, highly educated, meticulously groomed and refined.  He doesn't smoke and is quiet and guarded.  Both are charming in their natural habitats, but the confines of a turquoise Cadillac Seville, initially at least, prove challenging.

Farrelly sets his stage between Manhattan and the Bronx, Tony using his last day at the Copa to con a mob guy, then raising cash by pawning his watch and outeating Fat Paulie on a $50 bet.  He lives in a cramped apartment that is clearly loving home.  When he locates Shirley's apartment above Carnegie Hall it completely contrasts his own, spacious with a servant (Amit, Iqbal Theba), towering elephant tusks, a Steinway grand piano and even a throne.

But "Green Book" is a road movie and once that caravan of two turquoise Cadillacs sets off, the second transporting The Don Shirley Trio's cellist Oleg (Dimiter D. Marinov) and bassist George (Mike Hatton), we off on one helluva ride.  At first, things aren't all that different, Tony amazed to be introducing Shirley to the music 'of his people' - Little Richard, Chubby Checkers and Aretha - which Shirley begins to appreciate even as he objects to Tony's constant nattering, distracted driving and smoking. Tony's amazed by their accommodations and the perks of the road under Shirley's touring contract. Knowing music from his extensive exposure in Manhattan clubs, Tony also recognizes Shirley's genius, listening to the man's piano playing with respectful awe. But soon after Tony's just about lost his mind over the joy of eating Kentucky Fried Chicken in Kentucky (and teaching Dr. Shirley, who's never had fried chicken of any kind, to throw the bones out the window), the Green Book's relevance kicks in when Tony pulls into the Carver Courts Motel. 'It looks like my ass,' observes Tony, reluctant to leave Shirley there while he stays elsewhere.

Tony takes his job seriously, becoming protective of his boss, demanding his contractual stipulations be met.  Where he once stayed outside tasteful gatherings, he now enters, witnessing rich white people fete the musician with, ironically, fried chicken, then deny him use of the house bathroom. A middle of the night call results in Tony learning something else about his boss, something scandalous for the time that Tony is surprisingly open minded about.  In one of the film's best scenes, Dr. Shirley, afraid Tony will now leave him mid-tour, tries to offer a promotion and pay raise that Tony will not hear of.  In another, Dr. Shirley helps Tony write a letter to his wife, one that expresses Tony's actual feelings instead of his usual litany of events, delighting Dolores back home.

Everything comes to a climax with a Christmas Eve concert and a rebellion against the Jim Crow South that ends in an unexpected musical performance of another kind.  Battling a snowstorm in order to get Tony home in time for Christmas ladles on more surprises.

There is absolutely nothing new about "Green Book," not conceptually nor cinematically, but it is just about note perfect.  It was Farrelly who thought of casting Mortensen, a brilliant idea as it turns out, the actor disappearing under an additional thirty pounds and the Italian American aura he soaked up from the Vallelonga family (who also star in Bronx set scenes).  Ali is also in top form, his protective shell thawing as he gets to know the man behind the brash bluster. Cardellini may only appear in a handful of scenes, but her presence lingers, a wife wise to her husband's ways who loves him unreservedly as we fall in love with her.  The period production is aces, locations around New Orleans standing in for the entirety of the Don Shirley Trio tour.  And, of course, the music is wonderful, Shirley's classical, jazz and Gospel compositions mixed with Tony's radio tunings.

Grade:  A-

Tony “Lip” Vallelonga (Vigo Mortensen) is the head bouncer at the Copacabana in New York, but the nightclub is closing for two months for renovation and he is out of work, Tony interviews for a job, and gets it, as a driver – for black concert pianist Dr. Donald Shirley (Mahershala Ali) on tour in the Deep South, during the height of America’s civil rights crisis in “Green Book.”

When I think of writer/director Peter Farrelly’s filmography, it is about such films as “Dumb and Dumber (1994),” “Shallow Hal (2001) or “The Three Stooges (2012).” Not the kind of movies with earth shaking meaning. So, I was not expecting “Green Room,” which Farrelly directs and co-scribes with Brian Hayes Currie and Nick Vallelonga (Tony’s son).

Unemployed but not wanting to do muscle work for the mob, Tony agrees to be Dr. Shirley’s personal driver. But, being a prejudiced Italian white man, driving a black man in the South, during desegregation in the early 60s, is not part of his makeup. Vallelonga sets down some ground rules. Number one is, “I am not your butler.” Tony will, though, drive and protect his ward during their journey in the Deep South amidst the inevitable hatred and bigotry.

What is missing from the above description is the realization of the marvelous chemistry between both Mortensen and Ali and Tony and Donald. The two travelers could not be more different. Shirley has a PhD in music, is a world-class concert pianist and has an upper class background of privilege. Lip is a working class tough guy who grew up on the streets of New York, loves his wife madly and has a passion for food – like Kentucky Fried Chicken and pizza. This clash of cultures, and its personification by the stars, makes “Green Book” far more than a buddy/road movie.

I have seen the TV spots for “Green Book” and they give the impression that it is a reversal of “Driving Miss Daisy.” That could not be further from what, to me, is one of the best films of the year. I give it an A-.
Back To Current Show
Next Show Previous Show
Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!

Home | Reviews and Ratings Archive  | Top 10 | Video | Crew | Article | Links

Reeling has been chosen as a Movie Review Query Engine Top Critic.

MRQE Top Critic Badge